Agenda and minutes

Apologies were received from Councillor Dr. Barton, Deborah Martin and David Trubshaw.

There were no declarations of interest.

The minutes of the meeting held on 23 January 2013 are attached and the Panel is asked to confirm them as a correct record.

RESOLVED:

that the minutes of the meeting held on 23^rd January 2013 be approved as a correct record.

Minutes 42, A) 2 Upperton Road, former CPH Thurmaston

Councillor Unsworth noted that a further application had been brought for the premises, and supported the decision of the Panel to strongly object to the application.

A) MARKET REDEVELOPMENT

Planning Application PRE-APPPLICATION CONSULTATION

Demolition of Market Hall, new food hall at side of Corn Exchange (Grade II* listed), new building at rear of Molly O’Grady’s Public House, public toilets.

The panel were very supportive of the overall scheme, they welcomed the demolition of the old market hall, which dominates the area and does not serve its purpose well.

There was a discussion about access to the toilets, overshadowing of existing stalls, the suitability of the roofing material for the new food hall, the rationale behind the ‘splayed’ design of the food hall and the potential to widen existing roads.

A question was raised about the potential re-use of the former fish market building. This would remain an aspiration, but was not readily achievable given existing land ownership arrangements.

The Panel raised NO OBJECTION to the application.

B) 121-123 LONDON ROAD, LANSDOWNE PH

Planning Application 20130156

Change of use of second floor from offices; 3^rd and 4^th floor extension to provide 17 self-contained flats.

The panel raised no objection to the change of use. They felt the existing building did not make a positive contribution to the conservation area, but did sit comfortably within the street scene, which stepped up along this section of London Road. The proposed alterations would unbalance the design of the existing building and obscure views of the side windows of the adjacent hotel, to the detriment of the conservation area.

The proposal would also be bulky and dominant and have an overbearing impact on the adjacent ‘top hat terrace’ building.

The Panel raised OBJECTED to the application.

C) BLACK BOY PH, ALBION STREET

Planning Application 20130155

Change of use from public house (class A4) with extensions to sides and roof to form 43 student bedrooms in 20 flats (no use class)

The panel felt that the proposed design was bulky heavy and dark, having an overly dominant impact on the pub building, which was an interesting and distinctive building.

They accepted the principle of an extension and change of use but felt that any new design would need to have a lighter, less dominant impact on the building which respected the features of the original pub and was set further back. The panel added every effort should be made to preserve the chimneys, which were a positive feature of the building.

The panel asked that the applicant take care of the interior features, many of which were of high quality, and re-use them elsewhere if they could not be incorporated within a redevelopment.

The Panel recommended SEEKING AMENDEMNTS to the application.

D) 7 CARLISLE STREET, FORMER HUNTERS REST PH

Planning Application 20130132

Change of use from public house (class A4) to fourteen 1-bed self-contained flats (class C3); first floor extensions and external alterations

The panel fully supported the scheme, they welcomed the re-use of the building and felt the design of the extension was sympathetic to the design of the original building.

They asked that particular care be taken to  ...  view the full minutes text for item 48.

The meeting closed at 6.43pm.